whos better mike portnoy(dream theater) or neil peart(rush)

[GlassMoon]

---

EZRA: The Mars Volta caught my ears when their video, Inertiatic ESP was aired. And I was even more amazed when I knew their bassist is John Alderete, who currently plays bass for Paul Gilbert in Racer X.

[depechebox]

but portnoys improvisation is simply amazing esp. live he kicks ass, but I like peart a lot, for short limpyo kaayo paminawon

[kennyadry]

Portnoy is not just a drummer, he is master at composing highly technical songs..

[pating]

Portnoy... nuff said...

[Bangkilan]

i say neil peart!!! i grew up listening to rush its too bad there aren't any bands just like them these days.

Thats fackin right.

ill go for Peart.! (long life rush fan here since elementary)

----

Mike is good drummer but when it comes to geeting Tighter, Cleaner and more musical Peart destroy him

portnoy is just a bunch of noise Peart was already been there before Mike was even playing Peart is

legendary and one of the most influential history, peart inspired Portnoy., mike just an amateur right

next to him.

-----

To sum it up peart is portnoys dad.

[Bangkilan]

Portnoy is God.

SAYOP KA. sorry

Portnoy was mostly inspired by peart ., Peart is God


-----

[libido]

for me ingon ani ang akong pag tan-aw:

Peart = Legendary
Portnoy = next in line to be a legend
Mike = will become a legend someday.

[Bangkilan]

Portnoy losing its grip , Peart spontaneously continues and successfully master his skills

[akenq]

Musicality and player in a band context..No doubt it's Mike Portnoy