Questions/Doubts/Wrong Practices to the Catholic Church--Analysis and Opinion

[necrotic freak]

---

^^akong pasabot there's no such thing as FREE nowadays.. bisag asa ka moadto. religious or not. hehe

[redhorse1L]

^^ Mao, kay murag sad baya wala magkinahanglan ug kwarta ang ubang Christian denomination.

May neh sila patukoron ug religious sect nga dili mangayo ug kwarta.
Kung mo-survive neh ilang sect nga walay kwarta, salute jud ko.

[splendid moonlight]

This thread is all about people ASKING questions about catholic doctrines, its either your a catholic that will defend you religion/doctrines or one of the people who have some questions about Catholic Doctrines.

Why mention about the Motives? Some people here are Just asking questions, right? Unless they say that Catholic doctrines are wrong.
Why just answer the questions being asked?

This thread is all about Answering questions on Catholic doctrines, Not questions on someones FAITH.

Are you really that naive? Yes you are right, SOME are just asking questions. Some, on the other hand, will "ask questions" as their way of saying that Catholic doctrines are wrong. It's happened too many times before. The rules of this thread can be easily manipulated. I was just hoping to remind those who consider themselves Christians, Catholic or not, to think about their motives, because again as mentioned in the bible, let the one who has no sin cast the first stone.

Anyway, that was all, I had no wish to participate in this topic. I was simply reacting to the first person to reply to this thread.

[SioDenz]

^^ Mao, kay murag sad baya wala magkinahanglan ug kwarta ang ubang Christian denomination.

May neh sila patukoron ug religious sect nga dili mangayo ug kwarta.
Kung mo-survive neh ilang sect nga walay kwarta, salute jud ko.

Needing Money is Different from Asking money. When Jesus was with the disciples spreading the word and healing the sick, they need money but did they ask? Nope. The bible mentioned that Jesus commanded that his disciples should Not ask for any money but spread the word instead.

Setting fixed Fees for Church services is for me Not good, especially if its a Holy Sacrament.

[SioDenz]

Are you really that naive? Yes you are right, SOME are just asking questions. Some, on the other hand, will "ask questions" as their way of saying that Catholic doctrines are wrong. It's happened too many times before. The rules of this thread can be easily manipulated. I was just hoping to remind those who consider themselves Christians, Catholic or not, to think about their motives, because again as mentioned in the bible, let the one who has no sin cast the first stone.

Anyway, that was all, I had no wish to participate in this topic. I was simply reacting to the first person to reply to this thread.

Ok, tnx for your reply.

[redhorse1L]

Needing Money is Different from Asking money. When Jesus was with the disciples spreading the word and healing the sick, they need money but did they ask? Nope. The bible mentioned that Jesus commanded that his disciples should Not ask for any money but spread the word instead.

Setting fixed Fees for Church services is for me Not good, especially if its a Holy Sacrament.

Bro, if walay kwarta jud ang tawo, then naay pabunyagan.. Kinsa man gud pari-a nga dili mosugot nga bunyagan kay walay kwarta? Or dili kaslon kay walay kwarta? Pwede ra jud ako saboton ang pari nga magkasal, walay budget, mga ginikanan ra naa, then 2 witness. Adto mangaon sa siomaiyan..

But the thing is, kung naay kasal, perti dako kaayo ug gasto, abang gown, palit sing2x mahal, daghan kaayo i-invite, full video-photo coverage, Dramatic entrance inig paso, honeymoon todo2x, .. Sa kadako ana nga gasto, pila ra man intawn ka-percentage imo bayaran sa simbahan compared sa imong gasto sa kasal?

Besides, asa na padung? Sa simbahan, para tabang bayad sa lights, maintenance sa building, of course tagaan sad ang Pari, kay wala baya nay lain source of income as regular employees..

It's just simply saying that you should also give some portion to the Church.. Don't be greedy with your own celebration.

[necrotic freak]

ug walay fixed fee (dili lang pod sobra kadako) unsa nalang kahay hitsura sa simbahan? hehe

pila raman nang mga fees sa simbahan oi.. mogasto man gani ta pila ka kahon redhorse.

[bunzbunny]

Hahahaha..... what a logic...

Ani nalang...

Go to school para makatrabaho then magkasweldo, Para naay ika hatag kung naay misa, naay pambayad kung naay bunyag, lubong, blessing og uban pa ^_^ . They dont do service free nowadays

Bro, if walay kwarta jud ang tawo, then naay pabunyagan.. Kinsa man gud pari-a nga dili mosugot nga bunyagan kay walay kwarta? Or dili kaslon kay walay kwarta? Pwede ra jud ako saboton ang pari nga magkasal, walay budget, mga ginikanan ra naa, then 2 witness. Adto mangaon sa siomaiyan..

But the thing is, kung naay kasal, perti dako kaayo ug gasto, abang gown, palit sing2x mahal, daghan kaayo i-invite, full video-photo coverage, Dramatic entrance inig paso, honeymoon todo2x, .. Sa kadako ana nga gasto, pila ra man intawn ka-percentage imo bayaran sa simbahan compared sa imong gibayad sa kasal?

Besides, asa na padung? Sa simbahan, para tabang bayad sa lights, maintenance sa building, of course tagaan sad ang Pari, kay wala baya nay lain source of income as regular employees..

It's just simply saying that you should also give some portion to the Church.. Don't be greedy with your own celebration.

mao pud na..
naa may nakabutang sa thread nga opinion..

show lang ko sa kong opinion..

kung pangutan on ninyo ang mga taw sa simbahan kung para asa na ang bayad sa bunyag.. kasal..blessing..

mu ingon rana cla nga donation na cya...dapat mu donate ang magpaservice..

if donation..
damat dli compulsory.
og dapat ang donation..walay exact amount..

same as halad..

og usa pa pud..
ingon cla nga ang kwarta ang nagdala og gobot sa kalibutan tungod sa ka greedy sa mga taw.

does it mean that the church needs money so.. is there a demon side in the church?..
does it mean that the church could also be greedy?..

or its just a plain donation with an exact amount and that service cant be done without it.

question lang hap..

[SioDenz]

Bro, if walay kwarta jud ang tawo, then naay pabunyagan.. Kinsa man gud pari-a nga dili mosugot nga bunyagan kay walay kwarta? Or dili kaslon kay walay kwarta? Pwede ra jud ako saboton ang pari nga magkasal, walay budget, mga ginikanan ra naa, then 2 witness. Adto mangaon sa siomaiyan..

But the thing is, kung naay kasal, perti dako kaayo ug gasto, abang gown, palit sing2x mahal, daghan kaayo i-invite, full video-photo coverage, Dramatic entrance inig paso, honeymoon todo2x, .. Sa kadako ana nga gasto, pila ra man intawn ka-percentage imo bayaran sa simbahan compared sa imong gasto sa kasal?

Besides, asa na padung? Sa simbahan, para tabang bayad sa lights, maintenance sa building, of course tagaan sad ang Pari, kay wala baya nay lain source of income as regular employees..

It's just simply saying that you should also give some portion to the Church.. Don't be greedy with your own celebration.

But the idea there is the church sets a FIXED fee. So you think tanan nagpakasal naa daghan kwarta? Ayaw ko ingna dili fxed akong bayranan if magpakasal ko sa Santo rosario church.
daghan mga couple di nlan paksal sa Church or Wala sah nagpakasal sa church kay daku gastu, apil nah na ang bayranan sa church.

Setting fixed fees is like forcing other people to give, where is the essence of Giving with an open heart on that?

[SioDenz]

ug walay fixed fee (dili lang pod sobra kadako) unsa nalang kahay hitsura sa simbahan? hehe

pila raman nang mga fees sa simbahan oi.. mogasto man gani ta pila ka kahon redhorse.

Jesus and his disciples did Not set Fixed fees, people give financial help with an open heart.

Again the issue is setting a Fixed fee. I dont think i can say I gave to the church with an open heart if someone sets a Fixed fee for my wedding rights.