Gary Granada vs. GMA Kapuso

[cute_6423]

---

just wanna share this..

...

The GMA Kapuso Foundation, on the other hand, released an official statement denying the accusations of Gary Granada:

“Mr. Granada claims that the lyrics used for the plug is his version. We dispute that. GMA Marketing provided Mr. Granada the complete lyrics for the music he was supposed to compose. He changed a word in these lyrics. With due respect to Mr. Granda, that does not make the lyrics, under copyright law, his version or his work.

“Certainly, Mr. Granada cannot claim sole authorship of the lyrics because he himself admits that GMA provided the lyrics and that he ‘rewrote’ portions of it, which means that he admits as well the authorship of the lyrics by GMA Marketing.

“Neither can he claim joint authorship of the lyrics. There is joint authorship when two requisites concur: (1) there must be an intention between the parties to be joint authors at the time the work was created, and (2) the contributions to the work of the party claiming to be a joint author must be independently copyrightable (see Erickson v. Trinity Theatre Inc, 13 F. 3d 1106[1994]).

“It is clear that the first requisite is lacking. For a work to be considered a “joint work,” two or more persons must collaborate with the intent to create a unitary work. In this case, Mr. Granada was engaged by GMA Marketing to write the music to the lyrics that had already been completed by GMA. Neither GMA Marketing nor Mr. Granada intended to be joint authors of the lyrics.

“The second requisite is also clearly absent. The changes to the GMA lyrics, whether all or some of them originated from Mr. Granada, are mere ideas, or refinements to it. In the case cited, it was held that ideas, refinements, and suggestions, standing alone, are not independently copyrightable.”

...

GMA Kapuso Foundation Answers Gary Granada’s Accusation : Starmometer.com

puro ra jud lyrics ila gitira...
di man lyrics and gi apas ni Mr. Granada...
amaw ai...
naunsa maning GMA oizt,
wa nmay respect sa copyright...
pareha sa usa kah video report sa TV patrol,
ila gicopy, then immediately gi air pud...
di ni maau dah

[dookiexave]

kung mag signature campaign si gary granada usa gyud ko sa una mupirma!

[realfussion]

nag pa blog2X pa.. murag bayot file kaso sa korte para kitang katag.... unsa may makuhaniya sa blog2x palaban sa mga blogger na igo lang mo saway labaw pang way ayo.. sakyan pas mga way nahut na blinded sa network war samot jud ang problema....

[hunt99]

na unsa nakaha ni rong hitabo-a

[SERENAvsBLAIRE]

mao sad. nihilom lagi ni? gibayaran na tingale ni? aw unsa ba? nag file na lng unta case pra ma resolve na ni or matagaan na justice if naa ba jud nalabag ang GMA.

[uwagan]

trial by publicity manang iyang gibuhat.. kun kahiabw cya nga naa cya sa saktong baroganan daritsu cya sa court. pasaka ug kaso. ngano ipa agi paman pud niya ug blog...

[szichri]

sometimes there is no other way than to go public... David ang Goliath ma ning problemaha... e feature sad unta ni sa GMA nga documentary Case unclosed.

[uwagan]

wa man gani pa niya gi pa saka sa korte nya ifeauture na nuon sa case unclosed. saonz


@szichri: samson and goliath? or david and goliath?

[szichri]

owwwsss.... david and goliath diay uwags... soweeee...

[dagski]

i sumbong ky Tulfo or XXX..