Telling the Truth: AIDS Rates for Thailand and the Philippines
By RENE JOSEF BULLECER, M.D.
Executive Director, HLI Visayas Mindanao
http://www.hli.org/condom_facts_thai...ids_rates.html
There has been a wealth of misinformation and misleading interpretations of facts surrounding the spread
of HIV/AIDS in Thailand and the Philippines. Anti-life forces, of course, continually push and spin facts while
working toward their deadly agenda. These organizations view condom distribution as the one great
solution to curb the spread of HIV/AIDS even though time and experience has proven just the opposite.
Recently, BBC and UNFPA's Director, Ms. Thoraya Ahmed Obaid, suggested that even calling into question
the effectiveness of the condom, as Cardinal Lopez-Trujillo, president of the Pontifical Council for the Family
recently did, would actually spread the disease. She boldly stated that "the statements of Cardinal Trujillo
could contribute to the further spread of HIV/AIDS."
Let's examine the actual figures:
The first AIDS case in Thailand was diagnosed in 1984, when a homosexual prostitute tested positive for
the disease. Later it spread among the female and male prostitutes, and among intravenous drug users.
The first AIDS case in the Philippines was also diagnosed in 1984.
By 1987, there were 112 cases of HIV/AIDS infection in Thailand and 135 cases in the Philippines.
In 1991 the World Health Organization (WHO) AIDS Program forecasted that by 1999 Thailand would
have 60,000 to 80,000 cases, and that the Philippines would experience between 80,000 and 90,000
cases of HIV/AIDS.
During that same year the Minister of Health of Thailand, Mr. Viravedya, launched the heavy-handed,
"100% Condom Use Program." All brothels were required to stock a large supply of condoms, and
condom vending machines appeared in supermarkets, bars and other public places. This initiative was
widely accepted by the people of Thailand. I was able to visit Bangkok in both 1994 and 1997 to see
this first-hand.
A year after this program was set loose upon Thailand (1992), the infamous Secretary of Health (now a
senator), Mr. Juan Flavier, tried to implement the program in my own country, the Philippines. This small,
4'11'' man tried every technique he could think of to get his country to accept the flood of condoms
waiting to invade. He even went so far as to mock and deride Church leaders.
Flavier's efforts in the Philippines failed, however, and in 1999 the UNAIDS reported 755,000 total
confirmed cases of HIV infection in Thailand-65,000 had died of the disease. That same year, in the
Philippines, the total number of HIV cases was only 1,005. The disease had killed only 225 people.
The discrepancy in the infection rates between the two countries, Thailand with severe condom-oriented
programs and the Philippines without, has continued and only grown wider. As of August 2003 there
were 899,000 HIV/AIDS cases documented in Thailand and approximately 125,000 deaths attributed to
the disease. These numbers are many times those projected by the WHO (60,000-80,000 cases) in 1991.
These numbers contrast sharply with those of the Philippines where, as of September 30, 2003, there
were 1,946 AIDS cases resulting in 260 deaths. This is only a mere fraction of the number of cases
(80,000-90,000) that the WHO projected would be reached by 2000.
Due to the unabated rise of cases of HIV/AIDS in Thailand, the UNPFA sponsored a meeting in Bangkok in
September 2003. Unable to curb the spread of the disease, they are focusing now on AIDS care. Ironically,
records show that majority of the AIDS hospice centers are currently owned and being run by the Catholic
missionaries, particularly the Camillian Fathers!
The discrepancy between the numbers of HIV/AIDS cases in Thailand and the Philippines is particularly
poignant considering that the Philippines is actually the more populous country. According to the U.N.,
Thailand has 66 million people. While according to the USAID-funded Commission on Population, the
Philippines is now home to 82 million souls.
To what does the Philippines owe its great success in the fight against AIDS?
The AIDS-Free Philippines which I personally organized in 1991 got the blessings from the Catholic Bishops
Conference of the Philippines in 1993 as the official program to combat the pro-condom advocates
nationwide. Despite extremely limited local funds (we never received any foreign funds) we were able to
spread our program widely among our target groups ranging from the Maritime students, inter-island
seamen, prison inmates, secondary and college students, civic organizations, and religious groups and institutions.
AIDS-Free Philippines is the only pro-chastity/abstinence and truth based anti-AIDS program in the Philippines.
I have participated in scores of radio and television interviews through these years and even debates (where
I debunked the claims of condom effectiveness) with pro-condom Department of Health officials and NGO's.
Our secret weapon is, of course, prayer. We always start each lecture, seminar, training session, and
convocations with a prayer and we always emphasized the moral aspect of the problem.
Of course, though years of experience in examining the differing AIDS infection rates in the Philippines and
Thailand would seem to prove beyond any doubt the disastrous ineffectiveness of the condom solution,
there are still efforts to implement these and similar strategies in the Philippines. Despite so much evidence,
the culture of death never gives up on the condom.