wanted to watch: PUBLIC DEBATES or FORUM for ISTORYANS in person

[nunobone]

---

yup, also what im worrying about... para nindot.. how about an outing and at the same time we will have a little debate,planning of future activities..

[n`gel]

Dili magpatuga tuga ug debate kung walay facilitator and ignorante sa mga rules of proper debate.

Maypa mag organize mo'g seminars about conserving our natural resources / recycling / daghan pa makaayo sa atong kainayahan.

[la_gnostic]

this could be a good activity among the members of istorya.net. i'll bring this up with the admins.

my only worry is the capability of the members to control themselves during and after the debate.

thank you , pnoize, hope nga ma-realize.

valid na ang imong worries, pero i believe mao jud hinoon ni ang reason nga mo-hold gyud og "face-to-face" debate for istoryans kay aron ma-train sila pag self-discipline ug aron masayod sila unsa gyuy proper nga debate. besides, naay rules ang debate ug naa sa'y kamao nga moderator nga mopatuman sa rules.

dili na makapatuyang and debaters ug yawyaw sa ilang gusto sama sa on-line debate kay kun face-to-face makita na sila sa publiko ug mauwawan sila kung magpatuyang sa ilang gibati.

nakakita na man seguro mo og inter-college debates, ingon ani unta ang himoon sa istorya.

Yes, an OUTING and a DEBATE is very okey. alegre jud na.

[la_gnostic]

Maypa mag organize mo'g seminars about conserving our natural resources / recycling / daghan pa makaayo sa atong kainayahan.

okay man sad na siya, pero lahi sad na nga siya activity. nganong limitahan man nato ang atong actitivities, nga lain-lain man ang atong makat-unan matag kalihokan?

[PissKhanXXX]

valid na ang imong worries, pero i believe mao jud hinoon ni ang reason nga mo-hold gyud og "face-to-face" debate for istoryans kay aron ma-train sila pag self-discipline ug aron masayod sila unsa gyuy proper nga debate. besides, naay rules ang debate ug naa sa'y kamao nga moderator nga mopatuman sa rules.

dili na makapatuyang and debaters ug yawyaw sa ilang gusto sama sa on-line debate kay kun face-to-face makita na sila sa publiko ug mauwawan sila kung magpatuyang sa ilang gibati.

good points are in bold.

[n`gel]

Okay, seems to me like some members want to organize events BUT not one of them has ever been materialized yet. We actually challenge members to facilitate their suggested events as so you know Admins and Moderators are often busy with family or work. I don't have anything against these events, the more members initiate the better. Thumbs up to whoever materializes this suggestion.

[trickyboy]

If a formulation of an even like this would likely happen, what will the form be? Informalism? or we do the parliamentary form of debates?

[M@rv|n]

hulat lang ko go signal ahehe volunteer ko para facilitator or time keeper

[diem]

do we have to make it so formal like a high school debate?! complete with the four parts of necessity, practicability, benevolency and then the rebuttal?

I suggest we keep it informal yet polite... without cheering crowds... kind of like the debates they have in NHK...

Of course, all participants should be screened...

[Blongkoy]

Debate is good. But there has to be a good moderator --- one equipped with the art of argumentation and debate (it is a reference book in college) and a set of rules.

Debate in a face-to-face situation is even better. We always notice a lot of braggadocio in Internet forum simply because they are faceless and thrive in the shadowy world of anonymity.

Debate in the flesh is most welcome. And, in the Korean style of democratic exercise, we all can square it off at the end of the day.

blongkoy,Â* can you organize a group to hold public or "face-to-face"Â* debates and discussions for istoryans?

i think sa imong tabang, madayon gyud ni.Â* kay tan-aw nako capable gyud ka mopasiugda og mga kalihokan sama ani.

nagtuo ko nga angay gyud nga naa gyud ikaayo sa mga istoryans. kay kung dautan ang debate, wagtangon na lang sa mga institusyon sa gobeyerno. imbis itudlo, i-ban na lang ni college.

nagtuo sab ko nga kung duna'y malingaw sa istoryan activities nga inom ug paminaw sa banda, duna sa'y ganahan matambong sa public debate ug diskusyon kay dili lang kay makalingaw, makapadugang pa gyud sa kahibalo sa naminaw.Â*

katong mga kusog kaayo mo-debate dinhi sa istorya, tingali anhi na sila makat-on unsaon nila pag-behave ug unsaon sab paghashas sa mga isyu.

la_gnostic,

I love to see your proposal materialized. But I cannot organize it these days and for some times yet to come. In my search for good food on the table, I am always out of town and I do not want to hold this important activity hostage to my wanderings.

But if you can find a way to realize this proposal, please count my support and participation.

For support --- I can have modest logistics moved in plus buy something to nibble while the debaters are showing their prowess in the art.

For participation --- I can possibly formulate the rules based on fundamentals of the art of argumentation and submit to a larger group for criticism and finalization.

If you have the schedule, please inform me about it much ahead of time so that I can block it in.

I just got back late last night and will be leaving again in a day or two (I am now on assignment to do a story for an independent channel on "what the revolutionaries at the turn of the century [19th century] ate during their time [food documentation]; then a feature narrative project is held pending, in the meantime.)