Why not? if the guy can afford it. the whole point is making a girl happy? right? but then again, money alone is not a very effective tool coz it lacks the power that it can't buy, and thats the power of the heart. but if join together, it surely can make a woman happy. just like giving an orig LV bag to your GF and telling her that it came from the bottom of your heart, and that, if she refuse coz its too expensive,then, you are also willing to replace it with the one from greenhills. i am sure it will bring a smile from her face.