Asay mas Maayo ug Performance: INTEL OR ATHLON?

[dmelsie]

---

check ni nga site sa passmark comprehensive list of cpu's nilas as submitted by users who test using there software at least naa sad idea makuha diri

PassMark Software - CPU Benchmark Charts

[idolpunk]

so heres my share para something intel side

from anandtech conclusion:

Sometimes the comparisons you think may be most difficult are the easiest to call. The competition at $70 is actually pretty well defined. Intel has the advantage in nearly all of our non-gaming tests; the E5300 is anywhere from 0 - 20% faster in most cases than the Athlon X2 7850. On top of the actual performance advantage, there’s a power advantage too. With the E5300 you’re getting a 45nm chip that can be cooled by a very low profile heatsink or kept nearly silent with a larger one. In either case you’ll have a cooler running computer, slightly lower power bill, and a more pleasant experience come summer.
If you’re building a gaming box however, the recommendation shifts entirely the other way. The Athlon X2 7850 is the clear winner in gaming performance, significantly outperforming the E5300. In gaming tests the E5300 is simply too cache starved and without an on-die memory controller, each trip to main memory is too costly to compete with the 7850.

The only difficulty comes in if you do both of these things - if you’re building a machine that will be used for demanding 3D games and other CPU intensive work. In that case it boils down to which you care about more and whether or not power consumption matters.

Quite possibly the most interesting take away from this review is that with the Pentium E5300 Intel delivers, at $74, a CPU that is faster than the original Core 2 Duo E6400. And as such, it's also faster than every single Pentium 4 ever made. If you're looking to upgrade from an older Pentium 4 system, it'll cost a lot less than you might guess.

the full review and comparison (take note they are all running at stock speed)

AnandTech: AMD Athlon X2 7850 vs. Intel Pentium E5300: Choosing the Best $70 CPU

if overclocking is involve owning na ang E5300 compared to 7850
ang weakness niya nga mo agi pa sa northbridge to communicate wtih the memory is ma compensate sa iya high clocks so maka match or molabaw pa siya sa 7850 in gaming kay mas pas pas na siya maka process man hehehe akoa ra pod na idea ha if nay dili kauyon aw inyo na na hehehe
x2 7850 sucks big time when overclocking tried and tested na nako, mag lisod na ko increase sa speed maski 500 mhz increase lang but with intel E5300 pwede 1000 mhz ang increase nyahahaha
if magkugi ka og research mostly even newbie overclocker can easily OC this procie at least 3.0 ghz at stock voltage i myself has tried overclocking E5300 with stock voltage at 3.4 ghz prime stable for 2 hours wala na nako matuli og sakto pa kay sa akoa friend na system to iya gipa optimize niya limited time ra hehehe gamit nako is gigabyte g31 mobo which is cheapo na sad

for more info on E5200 overclocking nay thread ni poldo ato diri

so with this we can say that

E5300
lower power consumption at load
runs cooler
fast in applications
lower performance in games because of lower cache
highly overclockable
price 3670 (based on pcx SRP price)

X2 7850
faster in gaming
consumes more power at load
mas init sa E5300
price 3850 (based on pcx srp price)

its your call which procie you choose

thanks alot brad...na educate gyud ko ani dah...at least na enlighten akong gamay na huna2x...hehee...



asa ang mas less ug power consumption but pas2x siya? ang Entel sa?



hehee...ang ako is more on applications, building websites and less games...maybe NBA,warcraft pero more on building websites..like Adobe, corel draw, dreamweaver and etc....

[deadchest2]

aw...for application purpose mas nahan ko sa intel .....mas ok siya ug performance

[dmelsie]

heres more
try to read this guide at least naa sad mga tips ani

Homebuilt PC Buying Guide - New-System-Build - Homebuilt-Systems

if i were you for that usage go for intel PDC E5300 if budget limited ka if dili aw try search for athlon 2 x4 cheapest quady u can get at a higher frequency 2.7ghz ang starting ana nga series

[EmpireState]

OK ra mo reply dre??Salamat jud sa mga advices...Naka kuha sad ko ug mga usefull information about asa ang nindot sa duha..Intel or AMD...Mo palitay sad ko ug bag.o na CPU...Budget nako 10k-11k..Try nako mo palit ug mga cheaper one...Thanks sa mga info guys...Naka tabang jud cya..

[play_chess23]

Currently, Intel Core i7 is the fastest processor available in the market... but it somes with a price kung dako imo budget go for an Intel... Pero kung tight imo budget go for an AMD processor... I am an AMD user, ako system kay Anthlon 64 2x, anaa cya limitations pero kumbati kaayo...

Word of adivce choose for an AM3 socket ug motherboard na ddr3 haron dili ka maglisod ug upgrade in the future...

[aticrossfire]

@TS ang intel kong tangtangon ang proc dayon ibalik walay mawagtang sa system ang amd kong tangtangon ang proc dayon ibalik dayon naay mawagtang sa system, ni base lng ko sa kong exp...
ang mga drivers mawagtang...

[vipvip68]

Ang answer ani is..... IT DEPENDS....


- IT depends on the Price/Performance in comparing two similarly packaged systems.

- It's not only the price sa processor but also the overall price sa platform... (CPU + Motherboard)


Generally speaking....

- Intel holds the speed crown and has been demolishing AMD sa high end since the Core 2 and now the i7.

- AMD remains competitive because it has good products sa low-end and midrange segments. Also, its platform (CPU+Board) is relatively cheaper compared to a similar Intel setup.


When you compare, don't just limit your decision on Intel or AMD... take a look at the overall system to see which of the two better suits you.


Ako Personally, for a budget of 17-18k, you would be better served with an AMD setup.

+ Cheaper motherboard
+ At this price point AMD processors are competitive or even a bit better than intel counterpart
+ AMD micro atx system has good enough integrated graphics (780G) so you won't need to spend for a useless low end graphics card. (you can save up for a decent graphics card later)


P.S. I've been an AMD user since AMD's K6 so I haven't had the chance to try Intel's offerings sa low-end segment... best if you hear from someone else who has personally used low-end intel products.

[idolpunk]

Proccessor : Intel Pentium Dual-Core E5300 3,250.00
Motherboard : Asrock Wolfdale 1333 1,895.00
RAM : 2GB DDR2 PC800 Kingston 2,095.00
Hard Disc : SATA 320Gig Hitachi/WD/Samsung 2,050.00
Casing : TZ-613 ATX W/ 500W BLACK 1,095.00
Monitor : LCD 17" AOC 717VWX Wide 5,695.00


Total : P16,510



vs.



Intel Pentium Dual-Core E6300 3,595.00
Asrock Wolfdale 1333 1,895.00
2GB DDR2 PC800 Kingston 2,195.00
SATA 320Gig Hitachi/WD/Samsung 1,995.00
TZ-616 ATX W/ 350W BLACK 1,095.00
LCD 18.5" LG W1943T Widescreen w/ DVI 5,995.00



P16,770


THIS IS MY PLAN..hehehe......

Hope akong mapalit ni by December..Ang prices are base sa Gaisano Interpace since barato ra sila compare sa uban....



comments guyz if unsay maau...asay mas less ug energy consumption...gamay ra ug kaun ug koryente nya pas2x ang performance...

if hatagan ko ninyo ug composition sa computer na nindot mas maayo...

thanks alot guyz!!!

[number_21]

i choose intel,,,,,application rman pud akong gamit,,,, sa akong na obserbahan lang,,,mas pas2 mo render ug video ang inteL compare nku sa AMD,,,,,unya mejo ongot2 ang video nga gi render nku sa AMD...i don't know why,,,,hehehe.....pero kung games,,AMD ko,,